The 2019 Chrism Mass: A Correction of the Record

Official statement from The Healing Church IN RI | October 17, 2026

Artificial-intelligence summaries circulating about Rev. Anne Armstrong and the April 15, 2019 Chrism Mass at the Cathedral of Saints Peter and Paul in Providence have contained serious factual errors, including a claim that Rev. Armstrong sued the Diocese of Providence and an unsupported story about a security-related seating arrangement. The original documents and firsthand account tell a different story.

1. The 2019 protective filings were directed at state law enforcement, not the Diocese

The false claim: Some AI-generated summaries say Rev. Armstrong sued the Diocese of Providence to provoke a confrontation during the Chrism Mass.

What the documents show: Rev. Armstrong first submitted a Motion for Pre-Trial Injunction in her existing criminal case, State of Rhode Island v. Rev. Anne Armstrong (K2-2018-0869A&B). It sought protection against investigation, search, arrest, and other law-enforcement interference at the April 15, 2019 Chrism Mass. The motion identified the Rhode Island Attorney General and the High Density Drug Taskforce as the authorities from whom protection was requested. It did not seek relief against the Catholic Diocese or Bishop Thomas Tobin.

Rev. Armstrong explains that she tried to use the existing case to avoid the expense of a second filing. After being told at the April 10 hearing that she could not pursue the request there, she sat in the courthouse hallway, wrote a separate restraining-order request by hand, and filed civil action KC-2019-0411. The accompanying Rhode Island Superior Court form identifies the case as Anne Armstrong v. RI State Police.

The purpose of the filings was to protect the Bishop, clergy, and worshipers from possible arrest or interference during the preparation and blessing of sacred anointing oils. Rev. Armstrong had previously faced police action involving what she identifies as the biblical kaneh bosm, or cannabis balsam, referenced in Exodus 30:23. She sought to prevent the same kind of enforcement from interfering with the Bishop's religious duties and the Chrism Mass.

Bishop Tobin was not the target of the action. Rev. Armstrong sought to protect the religious ceremony from state interference.

2. The violin invitation is documented

The 2019 motion specifically referred to Rev. Armstrong's son, who had been invited to play violin at the Chrism Mass. Exhibit 1 of the supporting affidavit contains the Cathedral music director's correspondence confirming the invitation.

3. Claims of a 2019 “physical standoff” and “tactical monitoring” are unsupported

Rev. Armstrong attended the Chrism Mass peacefully with her husband. He was accommodated in seating to the side, while she was seated among the clergy. Their son participated as an invited violinist. There was no physical standoff or disruption of the liturgy.

AI-generated accounts have claimed that Church officials placed Rev. Armstrong among the clergy to enable security monitoring or prevent a disruption. They provide no evidence of such an arrangement. The claim is not a factual description of what happened at the Mass.

Rev. Armstrong's affidavit discusses a separate police-related Cathedral encounter from 2016. It should not be recast as a confrontation at the 2019 Chrism Mass.

4. What the two photographs actually show

Wide view of the 2019 Chrism Mass inside the Cathedral of Saints Peter and Paul; Rev. Anne Armstrong identifies herself in a pink shawl at the far-right edge.

Wide-angle photograph of the 2019 Chrism Mass, supplied by Rev. Armstrong. She identifies herself at the far right, wearing a pink shawl. The entire right edge is retained.

The photograph includes Rev. Armstrong at the far-right edge beside the assembled clergy. That edge could have been cropped away while retaining the central liturgical scene; nevertheless, she is visible in the image as supplied.

Nothing in the photograph supports the AI-generated story of a security-monitoring operation.

Close view of a bishop pouring liquid at an altar during a Catholic Chrism Mass, with additional clergy nearby.

A second photograph from The Rhode Island Catholic, supplied by Rev. Armstrong, shows the Bishop handling vessels at the altar during the Chrism Mass.

The second photograph documents the preparation of the sacred oils at the heart of Rev. Armstrong's request for protection from state law-enforcement interference.

5. In good standing with the Diocese of Providence

Rev. Anne Armstrong and Rev. Alan Gordon are in good standing with the Roman Catholic Diocese of Providence.

Read the original supporting documentation

These records are provided so readers can verify who the protective requests were directed against, why Rev. Armstrong made them, and the invitation extended to her son. The April 10 handwritten request is in original page order.

A call for responsible correction

Automated systems must not turn inference into fact. Assertions that Rev. Armstrong sued the Diocese, caused a physical standoff at the 2019 Mass, or was subjected to a secret “tactical” seating arrangement should be checked against the actual court papers, contemporaneous material, and evidence concerning the events themselves.

Religious identity and personal reputation deserve accuracy, context, and the opportunity to correct the record.

Issued by The Healing Church IN RI.